The keyword chart has been on the wall since September, and the class can recite it. Altogether means add. Left means subtract. Then the unit check comes back and half the room has answered “Priya has 18 more stickers than Owen. Priya has 45 stickers. How many stickers does Owen have?” with 45 + 18, the word “more” circled twice. They did exactly what the chart told them to do.
- Why Does the Keyword Chart Work Until It Doesn't?
- Which Word Problem Keywords Mislead, and on Which Problems?
- How Do You Check Whether Your Class Reads or Scans?
- What Goes on the Wall Instead of the Keyword Chart?
- How Do You Switch a Class Over Without Losing Your Weakest Readers?
- What Changes When Students Name the Situation First?
- Related guides
So should you still teach word problem keywords? We’d take the chart down and put up the situations students can name, like something joining a group or two amounts being compared. The words describe the situation, and the situation decides the operation. First, run the 8-problem check below to see whether your class reads or scans.
Key Takeaways
| Step | What to do |
|---|---|
| Run first | The 8-problem check: ten minutes, equations only |
| Take down | The keyword chart (keep comparison words as vocabulary) |
| Put up | A seven-situation chart from the Common Core tables |
Why Does the Keyword Chart Work Until It Doesn’t?
The chart earns its place early on: the words usually match the operation, and a weak reader gets something to hold. When it slips, the natural fix is more rows or a list of “tricky ones”. Most of us were handed the chart this way, so patching it feels responsible.
The What Works Clearinghouse practice guide on math intervention in the elementary grades (IES, 2021) covers grades K–6 intervention. Its word-problem recommendation is rated strong evidence, based on 18 studies. On keywords it is blunt: “Avoid teaching key words that link specific words to operations.” Its reasons: keywords let students skip reading the whole problem, a problem with no taught keyword leaves them stuck and a multi-step problem can hold two keywords pointing different ways.
The Common Core’s own situation table notes that when “more” is used for the smaller amount, the problem is harder. A 2025 study of 112 third graders found most could write the right equation when “more” meant add, and fewer when it didn’t; students who already found math hard were hit hardest.
In our reading, the misses bunch up on comparisons, missing starts and division, and the reteach week that follows goes to unpicking the chart.
Which Word Problem Keywords Mislead, and on Which Problems?
On the usual list of word problem keywords, in all and altogether mean add; left and fewer mean subtract; each and times mean multiply; share and per mean divide. Many of those words also appear in problems that need a different operation. The words describe the situation, so students should name the situation first and choose the operation second.
| Keyword (chart says) | Where it points the wrong way | What is happening |
|---|---|---|
| more (add) | Item 2: 18 more stickers than Owen | Compare, smaller amount missing |
| left (subtract) | Item 3: apples left after a picnic | Take from, start missing |
| each (multiply) | Item 5: 72 chairs in 8 equal rows | Equal rows, row size missing |
| fewer (subtract) | Item 6: 15 fewer points | Compare, bigger amount missing |
| times (multiply) | Item 7: 4 times as tall | Compare by times, smaller amount missing |
| of (multiply) | Item 8: three quarters of a club | Part of a whole, whole missing |
The IES guide’s own table lists eight such words; in its egg example, “altogether” turns 4 cartons of 12 eggs into 4 + 12 = 16.
How Do You Check Whether Your Class Reads or Scans?
Give the eight problems in one ten-minute sitting. Students write only the equation, with a box for the unknown. Read aloud for weak decoders. In items 1 and 4 the keyword points the right way; in the other six it doesn’t, and the bonus has none.
- A class collected 36 cans on Monday and 18 more cans on Tuesday. How many cans did they collect in the two days?
- Priya has 18 more stickers than Owen. Priya has 45 stickers. How many stickers does Owen have?
- After a picnic, 7 apples were left in the bag. The class had eaten 29. How many apples were in the bag at the start?
- There are 6 tables with 4 students at each table. How many students are there in all?
- A teacher sets out 72 chairs in 8 rows, with the same number of chairs in each row. How many chairs are in each row?
- Team A scored 15 fewer points than Team B. Team A scored 48 points. How many points did Team B score?
- A tree is 4 times as tall as a fence. The tree is 10 meters tall. How tall is the fence?
- Three quarters of the students in a club are in grade 7. There are 18 grade 7 students. How many students are in the club?
Bonus: 130 people are going on a school trip in same-size buses. One bus has 40 seats, and everyone needs a seat. How many buses does the trip need?
Answer key (any equation that fits the story counts, such as ? + 18 = 45):
| Item | Equation | Answer | The keyword answer |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 36 + 18 | 54 | Same (consistent) |
| 2 | 45 − 18 | 27 | 45 + 18 = 63 |
| 3 | 29 + 7 | 36 | 29 − 7 = 22 |
| 4 | 6 × 4 | 24 | Same (“in all” alone: 6 + 4 = 10) |
| 5 | 72 ÷ 8 | 9 | 72 × 8 = 576 |
| 6 | 48 + 15 | 63 | 48 − 15 = 33 |
| 7 | 10 ÷ 4 | 2.5 meters | 10 × 4 = 40 |
| 8 | 18 ÷ 3/4 | 24 | 3/4 × 18 = 13.5 students |
| Bonus | 130 ÷ 40 = 3.25, round up | 4 buses | No keyword to grab |
This is how we’d read the sheets.
- Right on 1 and 4, wrong on most of the rest: the class is scanning for words.
- Wrong on 1 and 4 too: the gap is the operations themselves, so start there.
- Right on nearly everything: your students already read the story.
- Bonus left blank: no keyword, no start (the guide’s second reason).
Grade fit: items 1–3 in grade 2; 1–6 in grade 3; all of them in grades 4–6; 2 and 5–8 plus the bonus in grades 7–8.
What Goes on the Wall Instead of the Keyword Chart?
The Common Core math standards already name the situations, from grade 1 problems “with unknowns in all positions” to grade 3 problems “in situations involving equal groups, arrays, and measurement quantities”. Their glossary sorts them into two tables, seven situations in all.
The situation names and missing-number positions are official; the student questions, examples and layout are ours.
| Situation | The question a student asks | A short example | Which number can be missing |
|---|---|---|---|
| Add to | Did something join the group? | A bus has 23 riders and 9 get on at the next stop. | The result, the change or the start |
| Take from | Did something leave the group? | A tray held 40 cookies and 14 are still there after snack. | The result, the change or the start |
| Put together / Take apart | Are there two parts and a whole? | Of 27 students, 15 walk to school and the rest ride the bus. | The whole or either part |
| Compare | Are two amounts compared by how many more? | Sam read 34 pages and Mia read 9 fewer pages than Sam. | The difference, the bigger or the smaller amount |
| Equal groups | Are there groups of the same size? | Five packs hold 8 markers apiece. | The total, the group size or the number of groups |
| Arrays and area | Is it rows and columns, or length times width? | A rug is 3 meters wide and 4 meters long. | The total or area, or either side |
| Compare (times as much) | Is one amount some number of times another? | A rope is 3 times as long as a 15 cm rope. | The bigger amount, the smaller amount or how many times |
There is no operation column on purpose. In the IES guide’s words, the same problem type can need different operations, so “it is not useful to associate a problem type with an operation.” Write “Compare = subtract” beside the chart and you have built a new keyword chart.
Keep the comparison words (more and fewer, older and younger) up as meanings. The guide suggests teaching them by how the quantity changes and pairing a problem that says older with one that says younger.

How Do You Switch a Class Over Without Losing Your Weakest Readers?
The plan we’d run takes four weeks, a few minutes a day.
- Week 1: numberless word problems. Show a story without its numbers, ask what is happening, then reveal the numbers and question. Numberless word problems, an idea popularized by Texas teacher Brian Bushart, keep students on the situation before anyone calculates. Use a warm-up where every answer can be defended on the other days.
- Week 2: one situation at a time. Give the full story with every number first, then the same story with one number missing. Students sketch first: two bars for a comparison, boxes for equal groups.
- Week 3: Three Reads and sorting. For longer problems, use Three Reads, a routine from Stanford’s Understanding Language team. In one common version the reads ask what the problem is about, what we are finding out and which quantities matter. Then students sort a mixed set by situation without solving.
- Week 4: words that point the wrong way. Build a mixed set with comparison and start-unknown problems like items 2, 3 and 6. Then rerun the check with new names and objects.
Weeks 2 and 3 borrow two of the guide’s Recommendation 5 steps.
In grades 6–8, run week 2 with the three multiplication and division situations and items 7 and 8, where “times as tall” and “of” get turned around. The IES practice guide covers grades K–6, so here the plan rests on the same logic and the standards. Pair it with a five-step routine students can run on any word problem and, for harder sets, original contest-style word problems with full solutions.
What Changes When Students Name the Situation First?
Back to Priya and Owen. A student with the situation chart in her head sees a comparison: Priya has more, so Owen has fewer, and the smaller amount is missing. She writes 45 − 18 and gets 27 without looking at the wall. The bus problem stops being a blank page: she pictures 130 people and buses of 40 seats.
The rerun check tells you in ten minutes whether your class has moved from scanning to reading. The chart on the wall still works when comparisons turn into “times as many”.
Gonit won’t teach problem types for you, and it isn’t connected to the guide, the standards or anyone named above. What it adds is practice: 10,000+ original Olympiad-style multiple-choice questions by grade and topic for grades 1–12, with accuracy shown topic by topic.
Related guides
- How to solve math olympiad problems
- Starting a math club
- Math enrichment for the child who finishes first





There are no comments posted here yet.
Sign in to leave a comment